DrivingSales Community Connections Update
There were a few places in our website redesign (DrivingSales, a social network for car dealer professionals) where functionality evolved as it was built but there wasn't any time to run it through design cycles. The "connections" portion of the user profile was one of those.
After hearing feedback from some of our users about confusion on this page, I reviewed the functionality and immediately saw the problem(s): There were a million priority buttons to press (green everywhere), and the various types of connections (follwers, those you're following and connections, i.e. following each other) were all lumped together in no apparent order.
I was able to break apart the different connection types, introduce a section for connection requests, and alphabetize all lists. If a request is pending, you're defaulted to that view. Then I defaulted all buttons to a secondary gray and cleaned up the dropdown menu. I also cleaned up the profile cover while it had my attention, adding valuable at-a-glance metrics and relocating the follow and connect buttons.
Takeaways
Listen to your users (of course), remember button hierarchy/emphasis, and make sure the user can easily accomplish the goal of the page.